Laws and fines
How ProsperitySMP handles problems between players, what a fine really means here, and the tools that protect you.
What this page covers
This page is about problems between players inside the economy: theft, scams, someone attacking you on a protected plot. Hacking, cheating, harassment and griefing are covered by the server rules, and those can get someone banned. So can scamming.
How this works
There is no automated police system and no in-game court. When something goes wrong between two players, staff look at what happened and sort it out by hand.
Staff have exactly three things they can do:
- Look at the record. CoreProtect logs who broke what, who opened which chest, and when. Chat and trade history are there too. Most arguments end here, because the logs usually say plainly what happened.
- Mediate. Talk to both of you and work out a fair outcome.
- Move money. If the fair fix is that one player pays another, or pays a fine to the city, staff can do that, as long as the money is there.
That is the whole toolbox. Read the next section before you count on a fine fixing anything.
How fines work
A fine moves money from the player who caused the problem to the city treasury. Staff issue fines by hand for things like theft, scamming, property damage, or attacking someone in a protected area. A player can always check their own record in game with /record.
The fine only works if the player has the money, and most players do not. The median balance on the server is about $50. The smallest fine on the books is $100, and roughly three quarters of players could not pay even that today. By the time you reach the fine for attacking someone, close to nine in ten players are short. When a player cannot pay, the fine becomes a debt recorded against their name. It does not vanish, but it is not cash in your pocket either.
So treat a fine as what it is: a mark on someone’s record and a bill they owe, not a guarantee you get paid.
Example fine amounts
Staff issue these by hand and hold the full schedule.
| Situation | Fine |
|---|---|
| Minor trespassing | $100 |
| Theft, low value | pay the victim back, plus $500 |
| Attacking someone unprovoked | $750 |
| Theft, high value | pay the victim back, plus $2,000 or more |
| Scamming or fraud | pay it all back, plus the same again |
When there is a victim, staff can also order the player who caused the loss to pay that victim back directly, on top of any fine to the city. Same rule applies: it only moves if the money is there.
What the server does not do
The old version of this page promised a lot that was never built. None of the following exist today:
- No jail. Nobody is locked in a cell. There is no bail because there is nothing to bail out of.
- No job restriction. Your ability to work and earn is never taken away over a dispute.
- No rank or title demotion. A fine does not cost you your rank.
- No bans for ordinary money disputes. Bans are for rule violations such as hacking, griefing and scamming (scamming also means a refund to the victim). See the server rules.
For money problems between players, the server records what happened and can move money to make it fair. Scamming is the exception, because it breaks the server rules.
How to protect yourself
The best outcome is the problem never happening. Two tools do most of the work.
- Trade through escrow with
/orders. Post a buy order for what you want and your cash is held safely until someone delivers the goods. The seller cannot take your money and run, and you cannot take their items and run, because the server holds the money and only pays out on delivery. See the wiki’s Trading guide. - Recover items from an expired rental with
/claimitems. If your rented apartment runs out while your things are inside, the server rescues them and holds them for you. Run/claimitemsto get them back. They are not lost.
For anything that has to move today between two people who do not know each other, use /orders rather than trusting a stranger to hand over their side.
Bringing a problem to staff
If another player has wronged you:
- Bring it to the Discord.
Either way, bring what you have: names, what happened, when, and where. Staff will not act on a claim with nothing behind it, and with the logs they usually do not have to.
